MINI Clubman vs MINI John: MOT reliability compared
Updated 05 September 2026.
12.8%
MINI John MOT failure rate, 1.5 pts lower than MINI Clubman
MINI John is the more reliable MOT performer: 12.8% of MINI John MOTs fail versus 14.3% for MINI Clubman, a 1.5 point gap.
| Metric | MINI Clubman | MINI John |
|---|---|---|
| MOT failure rate | 14.3% | 12.8% |
| Tests analysed | 218,986 | 146,908 |
| Most common failure | Tyres (38.2%) | Tyres (48.8%) |
Questions and answers
Which is more reliable, MINI Clubman or MINI John?
MINI John is the more reliable MOT performer: 12.8% of MINI John MOTs fail versus 14.3% for MINI Clubman, a 1.5 point gap.
What is the MOT failure rate of the MINI Clubman?
14.3% of MINI Clubman MOT tests result in a failure, from 218,986 tests.
What is the MOT failure rate of the MINI John?
12.8% of MINI John MOT tests result in a failure, from 146,908 tests.